Night-Shift Nurse Wins $1,536 in HDB Rental Dispute Over Daytime Air-Con Use

Night-Shift Nurse Wins $1,536 in HDB Rental Dispute Over Daytime Air-Con Use

Summary:

A night-shift nurse in Singapore was awarded $1,536.47 by the Small Claims Tribunals following a bitter dispute with her HDB landlord over daytime air-conditioning. The payout includes the return of her $800 security deposit, which the landlord had wrongfully withheld after the tenancy ended prematurely due to harassment.

The conflict centered around the nurse's need to sleep during the day. While her rental agreement explicitly allowed up to eight hours of air-con use daily regardless of the time, the landlord's daughter grew upset. Because the nurse and her roommate (another night-shift nurse) worked different shifts, the air-con compressor sometimes ran for up to 16 hours a day. The daughter retaliated by shouting at the tenants, shutting off the main power supply to disrupt their sleep, and eventually giving them an ultimatum to pay higher rent, restrict their daytime AC use, or move out.

After the nurses moved out, the landlord refused to return their security deposits. During the ensuing legal process, the magistrate strongly criticized the landlord for a "conspicuous lack of respect." The landlord repeatedly failed to attend tribunal hearings, using a fractured leg as an excuse but failing to provide the required medical certificates. She also attempted to make unsubstantiated counterclaims, including alleging damage to a bed frame and accusing the nurse of bringing a boyfriend over.

Ultimately, the magistrate dismissed all of the landlord's excuses and counterclaims. He noted that there were no rules in the contract forbidding visitors and ruled that a landlord cannot withhold a security deposit simply to cover higher-than-expected electricity bills. The magistrate emphasized that fluctuating utility costs are a normal risk of offering a fixed-rent agreement, firmly deciding the case in the nurse's favor.

+++

Source & Credit: