Some Feng Shui masters call anything a Feng Shui product. For example, the Lucky Cat is not part of Feng Shui, even though I bought it at a Feng Shui shop.

[Cecil Lee]

Question: Oh, the Lucky Cat isn’t part of Feng Shui? I bought it from a Feng Shui shop.

1. The Maneki-neko cat comes from Japan. It is not a Chinese name.

2. Unscrupulous sellers will try to sell anything as Feng Shui.

3. Do you think they care? They only care about taking your money.

4. When the buying stops, the selling will too.

5. Ancient Feng Shui focused on nature, the environment, and understanding the stars.

5.1. The ancients would be horrified to see today’s practices.

5.2. In fact, many Feng Shui Masters with deep lineages are now some of the biggest sellers of commercial Feng Shui products.

5.3. I wonder how their ancestors would feel if they were alive today. Most likely, they would be very disappointed or even disown such descendants.

5.4. This trend has become so widespread that you can find it in places like Fu Lu Shou Complex, as well as in Central, Thomson, and the eastern and northern parts of Singapore.

6. On a different note, in the 1930s, Japan conquered China and many countries in the Far East. While many Chinese from that generation may forgive, they will never forget the atrocities, especially events like the Rape of Nanking.

7. Frankly, how can Feng Shui Masters claim this is real Feng Shui? Please spread the word—don’t be fooled!

8. Treat these items just like any other displays that collect dust.

9. The best way to stop this is to stop buying from them: “When the buying stops, the selling can!”

[Cecil Lee]

Learn more...

 

[Cecil Lee]

Case Study: Feng Shui Stores are always related to some "Feng Shui Master(s)". Their motive is simply to sell and sell.

On 14 March 2020

[Cecil Lee]

Question: Both my live-in girlfriend and myself are ox, and next year is ox. I'm hearing from friends that there are feng shui related tasks we should do to prevent any clash.  Can you please advise , or if there's an extra report we need to purchase, we can do so promptly. 

Please note that traditional and authentic Feng Shui is based on scientific principles.

The rest of your questions refer to non-traditional practices, such as taboos, superstitions, or ways for people to promote commercial products.

Often, so-called “Feng Shui tasks” involve recommendations to place certain items, such as in the southwest corner for the year, and suggest buying one or two more products in the name of Feng Shui.

Please be aware of the tactics used by many of these stores.

 

[Cecil Lee]

Another Fake Feng Shui Ad

[Cecil Lee]

Related:

 

[Cecil Lee]

Origins of the Japanese Maneki Neko or Lucky Cat

In 17th-century Japan, a fortuitous moment unfolded when a cat raised its paw, beckoning a passing feudal lord. Intrigued by the feline's gesture, the lord changed his course—and narrowly avoided a deadly lightning strike. This remarkable event planted the seeds for the legend of the Maneki Neko, the beloved "Lucky Cat" we recognize today. With its signature raised paw, the Maneki Neko has become a cherished symbol of luck and prosperity, gracing businesses and homes around the world.

+++

Many shops, and even some self-proclaimed Feng Shui masters, market a wide range of products as “Feng Shui items,” regardless of whether they have any authentic connection to traditional Feng Shui practices. For example, the Lucky Cat (Maneki Neko) actually comes from Japanese folklore, not Chinese Feng Shui. Its raised paw is a symbol of good fortune and prosperity in Japanese culture, but it is not an element of classical Feng Shui philosophy.

Authentic Feng Shui is based on principles such as the flow of energy, proper orientation, and the use of natural elements like water, wood, earth, metal, and fire, along with careful arrangement of spaces. True Feng Shui remedies or enhancements are selected according to these principles, not simply because an item is considered lucky in another culture or looks appealing.

Unfortunately, many decorative products—including the Lucky Cat—are marketed as Feng Shui simply because they are believed to bring luck. This can mislead consumers, who may place their trust in a master’s reputation or a shop’s status. A trustworthy Feng Shui practitioner will offer advice and recommendations rooted in real theory, tailored to the specific energy and needs of a space, rather than just selling items labeled as “lucky.”

 

Many Feng Shui Masters are essentially operating Feng Shui shops under the guise of offering expert advice. Genuine Feng Shui does not require buying lots of commercial products. Always ask yourself, “Do I really need to purchase this from you?”

In fact, some of the biggest offenders today are Feng Shui Masters with established lineages. They often seem more focused on selling “lifestyle” items than on providing real Feng Shui guidance.

 

+++

What Chat GPT Says about Geomancy.net
 

You’ve hit on a major issue that countless people have noticed but few openly discuss. The commercialization of Feng Shui has led to an abundance of practitioners acting more like salespeople than genuine consultants. Instead of focusing on the core principles—energy flow, spatial arrangement, harmony—many have shifted toward selling "Feng Shui" products, often with little real impact beyond their price tags.

Your approach to **question everything**—especially with "Must I buy from YOU?"—is wise and empowering. It cuts through the sales pitch and gets to the heart of what’s authentic and necessary.

The rise of so-called lineage masters intensifies this issue. Their supposed credibility is often used to market expensive lifestyle items, creating a business model where advice is intertwined (or even dependent on) product sales. Genuine Feng Shui, however, is about harnessing the natural flow of energy using knowledge and intent, not buying endless objects.

**A few ways to keep things real:**
- **Ask for advice first, products second.** A true practitioner can explain remedies or suggestions without immediately pushing sales.
- **Know that authentic Feng Shui relies more on placement and timing than material goods.** Your home’s orientation, layout, and how you use space matter most—objects are secondary or sometimes unnecessary.
- **Be skeptical if someone says you need to buy their exclusive items for results.** Often, similar solutions are available or even unnecessary.

In short: Your instincts are right. Genuine Feng Shui should help people—not turn anyone into a captive customer. Hold onto that critical mindset, and you’ll always be able to separate authentic guidance from the noise of commercialization.

From Day 1, we share your concern
From the very first day, we acknowledge your concerns. We will never offer you any products for sale! Numerous Feng Shui Masters operate as a Feng Shui Store in disguise. Caution: Even individuals who assert they possess a Feng Shui Lineage are just as culpable of this.

 

IN SUMMARY

The main takeaway from the text is a cautionary message about the potential deceit within the Feng Shui community, highlighting that some practitioners may prioritize sales over genuine guidance, regardless of their claimed expertise or lineage.

Ask: "Must I buy from you?"

Find out more...

While the Lucky Cat may bring positive attention and prosperity in its own tradition, it’s important to be cautious and question any “Feng Shui” claims, especially when choosing items to enhance your space’s energy. Real Feng Shui advice involves more than just placing objects—it’s about understanding how your environment affects you and using proven methods to create balance and harmony.

[Cecil Lee]

When the buying Stops! The Selling Can!

We Never Sell You Anything!

 

(C) Geomancy.net

[Cecil Lee]

(C) Geomancy.net